Why Whistleblowing Protections Are Not Enough
.png)
The launch of the CIISA standards marked a significant moment for the creative industries, signalling growing recognition of the need for stronger protections around bullying, harassment and misconduct across film, television and wider media environments.
But in a recent article for Broadcast Now, we highlight that whistleblowing protections alone will not solve the deeper cultural issues that have allowed harmful behaviour to persist for years.
Here is a taster of what our CEO and Co-Founder, Gemma McCall, discusses:
"It’s this silence that has created the whisper network, an informal system that many workers have trusted far more than formal reporting channels – whether that’s an informal DM warning a friend off a certain producer, or a WhatsApp thread that circulates information about abusers or toxic environments that people are scared to say out loud."
The article examines how a lack of trust in formal reporting systems has pushed many workers within the creative industries towards informal warning networks instead. In sectors shaped by freelance work, short-term contracts and power imbalances, many individuals still fear career repercussions for speaking up publicly.
Gemma also explores why the introduction of CIISA should be viewed as an opportunity for meaningful cultural reform rather than a purely procedural response to industry scrutiny.
"The industry needs to treat CIISA as an opportunity to create lasting cultural change, not just a compliance checklist."
Alongside discussing whistleblowing protections and accountability, we highlight the importance of trusted reporting pathways, psychological safety and visible action when concerns are raised. Without this, organisations risk reinforcing the same silence and mistrust that allowed harmful behaviour to become embedded in the first place.
Read our full article in Broadcast Now to explore what lasting cultural change could look like for the creative industries and why compliance alone will not be enough.
.png)
What we're reading
Latest insights from the front lines of workplace culture.
What Happens Before a Misconduct Panel? Lessons from the University of Sussex
At a recent Community of Practice session, colleagues from the University of Sussex shared how they've strengthened their student misconduct processes. One insight stood out: successful outcomes don't start in the hearing room. They start long before a panel is ever convened.
The Tribunal Risk HR Leaders Can't Ignore
Featured in HR News, our latest research in the Culture Shifters Annual Report 26-27 reveals a stark gap between how confident HR professionals feel about sexual harassment compliance and what they can actually prove. Of 300 senior UK HR professionals surveyed, 91% said they're confident their organisation could evidence taking "all reasonable steps" to prevent sexual harassment if challenged today. But when asked to demonstrate specific measures, the evidence often isn't there. Only half can show clear reporting processes are in place. Only a third have measures to prevent retaliation.
The Hidden Costs of Workplace Misconduct in Financial Services
Join Ash McDowell, Chief Financial Officer at Culture Shift, and Christine Bonney, Head of Culture Transformation, as they explore the true cost of workplace misconduct in financial services and what organisations can do to reduce both risk and cost.
Feeling inspired?
Take the first step toward preventative misconduct management with a demo of our Report + Support™ platform. We can show you how to breakdown reporting barriers with anonymous 2-way messaging, and how to act before things escalate with name-matching and pattern-spotting across our analytics dashboard.
